Buck Stove Model 91 Wood Stove Review 2024

From the cozy warmth of a winter evening to the ambiance it brings to a room, wood stoves have a unique charm that’s hard to beat. Buck Stove’s Model 91 is one such offering that promises to offer warmth, style, and efficiency. Having used this stove firsthand, let me delve deep into what makes it tick, how it compares with its rivals, and the key decision-making factors that may influence your purchase.

Check price on Tractor Supply

Personal Experience

I’ve used the Buck Stove Model 91 Wood Stove for quite some time and have been quite impressed with its capabilities. The Model 91 is one of Buck Stove’s most powerful non-catalytic units. It was efficient and consistently provided ample heat for my large space, covering around 3,200 sq. ft. with ease.

With the ability to handle logs up to 21 inches in length, I found that I didn’t have to reload them frequently. This was particularly beneficial during cold winter nights when I didn’t want to get up constantly to feed the fire.

Its traditional design exudes a classic wood stove appeal, and the build quality is quite durable, suggesting it can last for years with proper maintenance. I especially loved the large door with its ceramic glass, which provides a mesmerizing view of the flames dancing inside. This visual feature is perfect for those cozy nights when you just want to unwind in front of a roaring fire. The built-in air wash system is also effective in keeping the glass clean for an unobstructed view.

Like any wood stove, it’s crucial to ensure correct installation for safety and efficiency. Regular maintenance, such as cleaning out ash and checking seals, is essential. I always consult a professional for installation and yearly maintenance checks.

One of the aspects I value the most is that Model 91 is EPA certified, which means it meets strict emissions and efficiency standards. It gives me peace of mind knowing that I’m reducing my environmental footprint while using it.

Overall, the Buck Stove Model 91 Wood Stove has proven to be a reliable and efficient heating solution for my space. While it requires the typical maintenance of other wood stoves, its performance, and aesthetics make the effort worthwhile.

Performance Metrics

• Heating Efficiency: With an 86% efficiency rating, the Model 91 is one of the top performers in the wood stove market. Most wood stoves range from 60-80%, so Buck Stove has managed to push the envelope here.
• Heating Range: It comfortably heats an area of up to 3,200 sq. ft. For an average-sized home, this is more than sufficient.
• Burn Time: On a full load, it can sustain a burn time of about 10-12 hours. That means fewer times refueling it during a chilly night.

Comparable Products to Consider

When I was on the hunt for the perfect stove for my home, I knew I had to consider the features, design, and cost of the top options out there. The choices can be overwhelming, but two names that kept popping up were the Vermont Castings Encore and the Quadra-Fire Adventure II. I took the time to dive deep into the specifics of each product to make sure I was making the best decision for my space. Let me share what I found out:

Vermont Castings Encore

• Design: One of the most standout attributes of the Vermont Castings Encore is its aesthetics. The model is renowned for its visually captivating and elegant design, which seamlessly blends functionality with beauty. This can be an ideal choice for those who place a high emphasis on the appearance of their stove, ensuring that it complements the décor and feel of their living space.
• Efficiency: The Encore doesn’t just score on looks. It’s also recognized for its efficiency levels, which are on par with many of its competitors, including the Buck Stove.
• Price: However, such quality comes at a cost. While the Vermont Castings Encore offers a myriad of features and benefits, it’s priced at a slightly higher point than some other stoves in the same category. This might be a deciding factor for budget-conscious consumers, but it’s essential to consider the long-term benefits and value of the product.

Quadra-Fire Adventure II

• Burn Time: The primary strength of the Quadra-Fire Adventure II lies in its impressive burn time. For those who desire a stove that can operate for extended periods without the need for frequent refueling, this product might be the top pick. Such an extended burn time can be particularly advantageous during colder months or in areas where the temperature drops significantly.
• Customizability: Where the Quadra-Fire Adventure II falls slightly short is in its customizable finishes. While Buck Stove offers a variety of finishes that allow users to match the stove to their specific interior design needs, the Adventure II has a more limited range in this aspect. Thus, if personalization and adaptability to home décor are high on your list of priorities, this might be a point of contention.

Both the Vermont Castings Encore and the Quadra-Fire Adventure II have their unique strengths and potential drawbacks. Your final decision should be based on your specific requirements, be it design aesthetics, burn time, customizability, or budget constraints. By evaluating each product against these parameters, you can ensure that you’re making the best choice for your home and lifestyle.

For those prioritizing efficiency and a long burn time, the Model 91 seems to be the perfect middle-ground.

Pros

1. Efficiency: The 86% efficiency rating on this stove is honestly fantastic. I’ve found that I use less wood to produce the same warmth compared to other models. Over the last few months, it’s saved me both time and money.
2. Customizability: The array of finishes available for the Model 91 is a blessing. I picked one that matched my living room’s vibe perfectly. It’s more than just a stove to me now; it feels like a piece of art tailored for my space.
3. Size: I’ve got a moderately sized living room, and this stove fits just right. It doesn’t feel too bulky or like it’s taking up too much space. It’s the perfect balance between presence and subtlety.

Cons

1. Weight: Okay, this thing is heavy. Weighing around 620 pounds, once I settled on a spot for it, there was no moving it. Make sure to plan its placement carefully!
2. Price: I won’t lie; it did pinch my pocket a bit more than some other models I looked at. But considering the efficiency and the customizability, I felt the cost was justified. It’s more of an investment for me, and I think it’ll pay off in the long run.

Decision-making Factors

When I started my search for the ideal stove, I realized it wasn’t just about the heat; there were several factors I needed to mull over. Here’s a glimpse into my thought process:

1. Space:
   • Assessing My Room: I first had to evaluate my own living space. Was it spacious enough to house a stove without feeling cramped?
   • Safety First: More than just fitting it in, I had to ensure there was enough room around the stove. I didn’t want any fire hazards, especially given some of the materials around my space. The last thing I wanted was to risk a fire.
   • Thinking About Heat: I also had to consider if the room would get too warm with a large stove or if a smaller one wouldn’t be enough. It wasn’t just about fitting the stove; it was about making sure the heat felt right.
2. Budget:
   • Upfront Costs: Some stoves caught my eye, but they came with a higher price tag. That made me pause.
   • Looking Long-term: However, when I thought about it, I realized that a high-efficiency stove could save me a lot on wood in the long run. It made sense: use less wood and spend less money. So, even if I spent a bit more now, I’d likely save more over time.
   • Value Over Time: It became a game of balancing the immediate costs with what I’d get out of the stove in the coming years.
3. Aesthetics:
   • My Style: Everyone’s got their own taste, and I’m no different. I wanted a stove that felt ‘me’, something that matched my personal style.
   • Fitting With My Space: I pondered on how the stove would blend with my room. Would it be the standout piece, or would it merge with my current decor?
   • Details Matter: I also took note of the material, the finish, and even the color. They had to align with what I envisioned for my room.

Overall Recommendation

Best Overall Wood Stove: Considering all factors, the Buck Stove Model 91 comes out on top for me. It strikes a balance between performance, aesthetics, and long-term savings. The heating efficiency means you’ll save on wood costs in the long run, making the initial investment worth it.

Craftsmanship and Build Quality

One of the striking things about the Model 91 is its build. Constructed primarily from robust steel with a cast iron door, it promises longevity. Buck Stove has a legacy of creating products that last, and the Model 91 is no exception. Every hinge, handle, and weld showcases meticulous attention to detail.

Installation and Maintenance

When considering any wood stove, understanding the installation and maintenance process is vital. Here’s what you can expect with the Buck Stove Model 91:

Installation:

• Venting: This stove uses a standard 6-inch flue collar. Ensure that your chimney or venting system is compatible and up to code.
• Clearance: Proper clearances from combustibles should be maintained. The Model 91 requires a safe distance, typical of many stoves, but always consult the manual and your local building codes.
• Floor Protection: Ensure that the floor beneath the stove is non-combustible or adequately protected. You might want to consider a hearth pad if placing it on wooden floors.

Maintenance:

• Ash Removal: Model 91 comes with a user-friendly ash pan, making the process less messy and more straightforward.
• Glass Cleaning: The large ceramic glass front remains cleaner than most, thanks to its air-wash technology. Nevertheless, occasional cleaning with a stove glass cleaner will keep the view of the flames clear.
• Gaskets and Seals: Periodically check the door gaskets and seals for wear and tear. Replacements might be required every few years depending on usage.

Fuel Efficiency and Wood Consumption

Although I’ve mentioned its impressive 86% efficiency, what does this mean in practical terms? Essentially, for every log you place inside, a vast majority of its potential energy is converted into heat. This translates to less frequent reloading and more consistent warmth. Moreover, its design ensures optimal combustion, meaning you’ll experience less creosote build-up in your chimney, which is a common concern among wood stove users.

Safety Features

When it comes to household appliances, especially something as elemental as a stove, safety isn’t just a consideration—it’s a necessity. In my experience with the Model 91 stove, I found it was meticulously crafted with safety as a top priority:

1. Locking Mechanism:
   • Purpose: One of the most noticeable safety features of the Model 91 is its door’s locking mechanism. This isn’t just any regular lock; it’s specifically designed to thwart unintentional openings.
   • Child Safety: For households with children, this feature is invaluable. Kids are naturally curious, and having a stove door that securely locks means there’s one less potential danger to worry about. It gives peace of mind knowing that even if children are playing nearby, they won’t inadvertently access the hot interior.
2. Cool Touch Handle:
   • Personal Experience: One of the first things I noticed—and appreciated—about this stove was its cool touch handle. It might seem like a minor feature, but when you’re frequently operating the stove, it becomes a significant advantage.
   • Protection from Burns: Traditional stoves often come with handles that can get exceptionally hot, posing a risk of burns. The cool touch handle on the Model 91 ensures that even after extended use, you can operate the door without fearing an accidental burn. It’s a testament to the stove’s thoughtful design geared towards user comfort and safety.
3. Overheat Protection:
   • Design Philosophy: A stove is a substantial investment, and any damage can be both costly and potentially hazardous. The Model 91 incorporates design elements specifically to combat the risk of overheating.
   • Safety and Longevity: Overheating isn’t just a safety hazard—it can also reduce the lifespan of the stove. By preventing overheating, the Model 91 not only ensures a safer environment but also protects your investment. An overheated stove could lead to fire hazards or compromise the structural integrity of the unit. With the overheat protection feature, these risks are significantly minimized.

Customization and Accessories

Beyond its standard offerings, there’s a slew of accessories and customizations available:

• Blower Kit: Enhances the circulation of heated air, ensuring even warmth distribution.
• Decorative Legs: You can opt for intricately designed legs to add an extra touch of elegance to the stove.
• Heat Shields: For those with limited space, you can add heat shields to reduce the clearance required from walls.

Final Thoughts

All in all, I’m pretty pleased with my Model 91. It’s a blend of performance, aesthetic appeal, and adaptability. There were a couple of challenges, particularly with its weight and cost, but looking at the broader picture and the benefits I’ve reaped, I believe it was worth it. If you’re considering it, weigh these pros and cons based on your own priorities.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. How large of space can the Buck Stove Model 91 effectively heat?
   The Buck Stove Model 91 is designed to heat areas up to 3,200 sq. ft.
2. What is the maximum log size the stove can handle?
   It can accommodate logs up to 21 inches in length.
3. Is the Model 91 EPA certified?
   Yes, Model 91 is EPA certified, meaning it meets the strict emissions and efficiency standards set by the Environmental Protection Agency.
4. How often will I need to reload the stove with wood?
   This can vary depending on the type and dryness of the wood, but its design allows for longer burn times, reducing the frequency of reloads, especially with larger logs.
5. Does the stove come with a blower?
   Some versions of the Model 91 come equipped with a blower, but it’s always best to check with the specific retailer or model variant.
6. Can I cook on the top of the Model 91?
   While it’s primarily designed for heating, the stove’s top can get hot enough to warm items. However, it isn’t designed as a primary cooking appliance.
7. Does the ceramic glass door stay clean?
   The stove features an air wash system designed to help keep the ceramic glass clean, providing a clear view of the flames inside.
8. What type of chimney or venting system is required?
   Proper venting is crucial for safety and efficiency. It’s always best to consult with a professional or the installation manual for specific requirements.
9. Is the stove catalytic or non-catalytic?
   The Model 91 is a non-catalytic wood stove.
10. How often does the stove need maintenance?
    Regular maintenance, like cleaning out ash and checking seals, is essential. Depending on usage, thorough cleaning and inspection should be done at least annually.

We’d love to hear from you! Share your personal experiences and thoughts about the Buck Stove Model 91 Wood Stove in the comments section below. Your insights could help fellow homeowners choose the right heating solution!

Reagan Key

Forestry Author