Elmira Fireview Wood Cookstove 1842-G Review

The Elmira Fireview 1842-G Wood Burning Cookstove with gas burners brings a nostalgic touch to any kitchen while offering modern functionality. As someone who appreciates the charm of wood-burning stoves, I found the Elmira Fireview 1842-G to be a perfect balance of aesthetics and performance. Whether you’re drawn to its vintage appeal or its dual-fuel capabilities, this cookstove delivers reliable results. In this review, I’ll share my personal experience with the Fireview Cookstove Model 1842-G, highlighting its features and how it performs in a real kitchen.

$8,595.00 USD on Obadiah’s WOODSTOVES

Product Specifications

• Depth: 36-5/8″ (with flue boot), 28-1/2″ (without flue boot)
• Shipping Weight:500 lbs
• Oven Dimensions: W 18-1/4″ x H 11-1/2″ x D 24-3/8″
• Oven Capacity: 3.0 cu. ft.
• Flue Size: 6″
• Firebox Dimensions: W 9-1/4″ x H 13-1/2″ x D 22″
• Firebox Capacity: 1.6 cu. ft.
• Log Size: 18″
• Secondary Outside Air: Yes
• Outside Air Connection: No
• Heat Output: 30,000 to 60,000 BTU/Hr.

Craftsmanship and Construction

The Elmira Fireview 1842-G Wood Burning Cookstove is a testament to superior craftsmanship, blending vintage aesthetics with modern durability. Its robust cast iron construction not only ensures longevity but also exudes a timeless charm that immediately drew me in. From its sturdy build to its intricate detailing, every feature of the Fireview Wood Cookstove feels thoughtfully designed for both functionality and beauty.

The nickel-plated accents add a touch of sophistication, elevating its aesthetic while staying true to its vintage-inspired roots. These aren’t just decorative they reflect the care and attention to detail that went into designing this stove.

This cookstove isn’t just about looks it’s built for performance. Its solid construction enhances durability and makes cooking an enjoyable experience. Whether you’re drawn to its nostalgic appeal or its reliable functionality, the Elmira Stove 1842-G is a worthy centerpiece for any kitchen.

Performance Accuracy

The Elmira Fireview 1842-G Wood Burning Cookstove redefines cooking precision, thanks to its innovative fireview window. Watching the flames dance in real-time turns temperature control into an intuitive experience, especially for tasks like baking or roasting where precision matters most. For me, this feature transformed cooking into an engaging and rewarding process, consistently delivering perfect results.

With a versatile temperature range of 200°F to 700°F, the Fireview Cookstove Model 1842-G adapts effortlessly to various culinary tasks, from searing steaks to slow-roasting delicate dishes. Its consistent and reliable heat control showcases exceptional engineering, making it a valuable addition to any kitchen.

Numerical Assessments

The Elmira Fireview 1842-G excels in performance across several key metrics:

1. Temperature Control: The range of 200°F to 700°F, combined with the fireview window, allows for precise adjustments ideal for baking, roasting, and grilling.
2. Cooking Surface: A spacious design accommodates multiple pots and pans, perfect for preparing family meals or hosting gatherings.
3. Gas Burner Output: Dual side burners provide 15,000 BTUs each, ensuring quick heating and efficient cooking for seamless meal preparation.

Installation Process

Installing the Elmira Fireview 1842-G is straightforward but essential for optimal performance. Start by choosing a well-ventilated space with a sturdy floor to support the stove’s cast iron build. Connect the stove to a proper chimney for safe smoke ventilation, ensuring all safety standards are met.

For the gas burners, follow the provided instructions to connect them to a reliable gas source. Position the fireview window carefully for a clear view of the flames. While setup requires some effort, following Elmira’s detailed guidelines ensures a smooth process. Once installed, the Elmira Fireview 1842-G offers a perfect blend of tradition and modern convenience, ready to elevate your cooking experience.

Table of Comparisons vs. Competitive

Comparisons and Considerations

When it came time to choose a wood-burning cookstove, I wanted something that balanced tradition and convenience. The Elmira Fireview 1842-G Wood Burning Cookstove stood out immediately. Its dual-fuel capability letting me switch between wood and gas was a game-changer. I love the charm of wood-burning, but having gas burners for quick meals felt like the best of both worlds. Sure, it’s a higher upfront investment, but after experiencing its precision and durability, I can confidently say it’s worth every penny.

Why I Love My Elmira Fireview 1842-G

After using the Elmira Fireview 1842-G Cookstove, I’ve come to appreciate its thoughtful design and features:

• Dual Fuel Convenience: Some days I cook hearty soups over a wood flame; other days, I just need a quick breakfast on the gas burners. This stove handles both effortlessly.
• Fireview Window: Watching the flames dance as I bake bread feels like an art form. Plus, it makes temperature control so much easier.
• Timeless Aesthetic: I wanted something beautiful that would become the heart of my kitchen, and the nickel-plated accents sealed the deal.
• Built to Last: It’s not just a stove; it’s an heirloom piece I know will outlive me.

Price Range: $8,595.00 USD on Obadiah’s WOODSTOVES

Why I Didn’t Pick the La Nordica Milly

I also considered the La Nordica Milly, and while it has its perks, it didn’t check all my boxes:

• Wood-Only Operation: I like the authenticity of wood-burning, but sometimes I need the speed and flexibility of gas burners, which the Milly doesn’t offer.
• Traditional Design: It’s nice, but it lacks the polished charm of the Elmira Fireview’s nickel accents.
• Budget Appeal: At $3,700.00 USD (available on LEHMANS), it’s more affordable, but for me, the added features and durability of the Elmira made the extra cost worthwhile.

Price Range: $3,700.00 USD on LEHMANS

Pros and Cons

Pros

• Timeless Design and Durability: The Elmira Fireview 1842-G features a timeless design with durable cast iron construction, adding both visual appeal and long-lasting durability to your kitchen.
• Precise Temperature Control: The innovative fireview window allows for precise temperature control, making it easy to monitor and adjust heat levels for various cooking techniques.
• Dual Fuel Capability: With powerful gas burners alongside wood-burning capabilities, the stove offers flexibility for different cooking preferences and requirements.
• Spacious Cooking Surface: The stove provides a generously sized cooking surface, ideal for multitasking and preparing multiple dishes at once.

Cons

• Higher Initial Cost: The Elmira Fireview 1842-G may have a higher initial cost compared to conventional ranges, reflecting its premium quality, craftsmanship, and unique features.
• Ventilation Requirements: The wood-burning feature requires a dedicated space with proper ventilation, which may pose a challenge for those with limited kitchen space or specific layout constraints.

Conclusion

After using the Elmira Fireview 1842-G Wood Burning Cookstove with Side Gas Burners, I can confidently say it’s more than just a stove it’s an experience. The perfect blend of classic charm and modern convenience, this cookstove has transformed my kitchen into a warm, inviting space where cooking feels like an art form. From its versatile performance to its timeless elegance, the Elmira Fireview has exceeded my expectations in every way.

If you’re looking for an appliance that delivers both functionality and style, the Fireview Cookstove Model 1842-G is a choice you won’t regret. It’s made my time in the kitchen more enjoyable than ever, and I can’t imagine cooking without it now. Trust me, cooking in style has never felt this good!

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Can I use the gas burners and wood-burning features simultaneously?
   Yes, the Elmira Fireview 1842-G is designed to allow users to use both the gas burners and wood-burning features simultaneously, providing flexibility in cooking methods.
2. What type of wood is recommended for the wood-burning function?
   Hardwoods such as oak, maple, or hickory are recommended for optimal performance in the wood-burning function. Avoid using softwoods, as they can produce excessive creosote and may impact the stove’s efficiency.
3. Is professional installation required, or can I install it myself?
   While the stove comes with a comprehensive user manual for self-installation, professional installation is recommended to ensure safety, proper ventilation, and compliance with local regulations.
4. How do I clean the cast iron surface of the stove?
   To clean the cast iron surface, allow it to cool, then wipe it with a damp cloth. Avoid using abrasive cleaners, as they can damage the finish. Regularly season the cast iron to maintain its durability.
5. What is the recommended clearance for installing the Elmira Fireview 1842-G?
   The stove requires specific clearances from combustible materials. Refer to the user manual for detailed installation guidelines, ensuring proper spacing to prevent fire hazards.
6. Can I connect the stove to an existing gas line in my kitchen?
   It’s essential to consult a professional installer to determine if your existing gas line is compatible with the stove. Modifications may be needed to ensure safe and efficient operation.
7. How do I troubleshoot issues with temperature control?
   If you experience issues with temperature control, check the alignment of the fireview window and ensure it is clean. Also, verify that the flue damper is functioning correctly. If problems persist, contact customer support.
8. Is the stove suitable for high-altitude locations?
   The performance of the stove may vary at high altitudes. Consult the user manual or contact the manufacturer for guidance on adjustments needed for optimal operation in such environments.
9. Can I use the gas burners during a power outage?
   The gas burners of the Elmira Fireview 1842-G require electricity for ignition. However, some models may offer a manual ignition option. Check the specific features of your model or consult the manufacturer for details.
10. What maintenance is required for the gas burners?
    Regularly clean the gas burners with a mild detergent to remove grease and debris. Inspect the burner ports for any blockages, and ensure proper ventilation to maintain efficient gas combustion.

We’re eager to hear your feedback! Feel free to share your personal experiences and thoughts about the Elmira Fireview 1842-G Wood Burning Cook-Stove with Side Gas Burners in the comments section below. Your insights can be invaluable for others considering this appliance, aiding them in making well-informed decisions for their culinary needs. Let the community benefit from your firsthand experiences!

Edward Smith

Forestry Author

Woodworking is about more than crafting; it's a harmonious connection with nature, mastering tools, and preserving our environment. I'm here to share my knowledge and experiences with you, forging a future where we can embrace wood's beauty and utility while safeguarding our forests' health and diversity.